Kaya Selbyn
RNZ Pacific journalist
New Zealand will foot the
bill for any cost blowouts the Cook Islands’ Penrhyn port
upgrade, new details about the funding arrangement
reveal.
That is despite Cabinet agreeing to greenlight
the project with the caveat that Aotearoa’s contribution of
US$10 million would be its “maximum”.
The project,
announced at the Pacific Islands Forum leaders’ summit on 1
September, is a joint proposal between the New Zealand,
United States and Cook Islands governments to build a
deep-sea port, extending a World World II American-built air
base.
The US and New Zealand governments will jointly
fund the NZ$101m project – the Americanscontributing US$50m
(approximately NZ$84m), while New Zealand will contribute
NZ$17.5m (approximately US$10m).
In a decision from 31
August – a day before the announcement – it was agreed that
the project would proceed, provided it passed a feasibility
study, the Cook Islands continued to support it, and that it
could happen “within the combined funding envelope approved
by Cabinet”.
A Cabinet minute prepared by Foreign
Minister Winston Peters’ office noted that the deal would
proceed, “only if we have confidence that the funding
available for the chosen project is sufficient to fully fund
its implementation.”
But this also appeared to be the
US approach, as the majority funder. According to the paper,
its US$50m contribution to the project is a “one-off fixed
sum”.
Advertisement – scroll to continue reading
“New Zealand would therefore be responsible for
any cost increases; this is a standard risk for all
development projects that New Zealand implements,” the
Cabinet documents state.
This is despite the fact that
the US is currently negotiating
the extent to which a military presence, which is
confirmed to include Coast Guard vessels, may be
accommodated on the atoll.
Though it acknowledged
construction would be “complex and expensive, given its
remoteness and lack of supporting infrastructure, local
materials or labour supply”, the unredacted contents made
little mention of the prospect of a cost blowout.
It
discussed the most likely benefits of the project, including
that it supports New Zealand’s “long-term objective to see
the US maintain its presence and standing in the
Pacific.”
High-risk, high-reward
The project
was born when the United States approached New Zealand in
April, offering an undisclosed sum of money and a commitment
to a port upgrade.
The initial sense from the Ministry
of Foreign Affairs and Trade (MFAT) advisers, according to
April advice released under the Official Information Act
(OIA), was that the project “will be possible, but it needs
extensive further work”.
It noted a 2023 feasibility
study by the Australian government – that New Zealand had no
part in – but the final cost estimate was
redacted.
“New cost estimates will need to be prepared
to support the project, which are expected to be
significantly higher.”
Advice from May also noted that
New Zealand had saved money, enough for “a reasonably
significant infrastructure investment”, because it had
paused aid to the Cooks during its year-long diplomatic
spat.
Officials said that New Zealand was working on a
US-led timeline at that point, and that without a business
case, it was taking on serious risks.
“Cabinet
consideration of a major New Zealand development activity
would ordinarily be supported by a detailed business case
prepared over a numbers of years with firm cost
estimates.”
As a result, the September announcement
was an intention to partner, rather than a sure thing. The
August Cabinet paper gave a plan to start construction in
2029 and finish in 2031.
‘Unusual
times’
Development expert Terence Wood said it was
possible that New Zealand was willing to take on the risk
for the sake of maintaining influence in the Cook
Islands.
“Given how common budget blowouts are in
large infrastructure projects, if NZ really is responsible
for all cost increases, it is taking a risk – one that it
would ideally avoid,” he said.
“But these are unusual
times. [New Zealand] desperately wants to keep the Cooks
away from China’s sphere of influence and it will be very
keen not to irritate the Americans.”
MFAT opened a
tender on 7 September for the study, with an initial
one-year contract of NZ$1.5m, followed by further work of
one to four years for NZ$3-6m. That alone could make up
about 43 percent of New Zealand’s overall
contribution.
Wood said that, from a development
perspective, it was not a good use of money.
“[But]
from a geostrategic perspective, it’s pretty easy to see why
the government is taking on the
risk.”


