Environmental groups are urging political leaders to
follow through on their promises and protect seamounts from
bottom trawling, as parties decide negotiation bottom lines
and the fishing industry goes on a PR
offensive.
Bottom trawling is a key election issue,
with all political parties taking a stance on the fishing
method due to growing public pressure and a clear scientific
case.
Environmental groups are now renewing their call
to implement seamount protections in the first year of the
political term, saying it’s a no-brainer for ocean
protection.
Karli Thomas, of the DSCC
says:
“Right now is a critical moment to end bottom
trawling on our precious seamounts, and most New Zealanders
wish it had already been done. Despite the trawl sector
claiming that any restriction on bottom trawling would spell
the end of the fishing industry, it’s simply not true.
Protecting all seamounts won’t make your fish’n’chips more
expensive, but it will save coral ecosystems from being
turned to rubble.”
A
ministerial briefing released under the OIA provides
data showing that closing all the seamounts at risk from
bottom trawling would result in only a 3.5% impact on the
deep sea fish catch. (1) (2) In the same briefing,
government officials emphasise that the fish could be caught
elsewhere.
Advertisement – scroll to continue reading
“We urge the political parties who are
holding a line on this crucial issue to stand strong and
commit to the ocean protection that their voters demand,”
says Thomas.
Seamounts are biodiversity hotspots, home
to corals and sponges that can live for hundreds of years,
and support an array of ocean life, including breeding fish
like orange roughy. International
resolutions call on states to protect seamounts from
bottom trawling.
Data shows that banning trawling on
these seamounts wouldn’t impact fisheries significantly,
and environmentalists argue the benefits to ocean health,
and fish numbers, would be huge.
In the absence of
protection, catch numbers for a key species trawled on
seamounts – orange roughy – are down significantly. In the
past five years orange roughy catch
has dropped by 49%. Bottom trawlers target these fish on
seamounts while they are breeding, in the process also
destroying their habitat and catching
large amounts of coral in nets.
The only seamount
that saw an increase in orange roughy numbers was one that
has been closed to trawling
for over twenty years.
Barry Weeber of ECO, who
has worked on fisheries issues for over 30 years,
says:
“It’s clear that protecting seamounts works –
in the few places where that has been done we see proof of
that. What’s galling, given the commercial fishing
industry’s current hysteria around profit and job loss, is
that without protections for most seamounts – their catches
are down anyway. This is because this type of fishing, on
these sensitive ecosystems, is not
sustainable.”
Seamounts are vital ocean habitats that
support a wide array of ocean life from coral to fish and
migrating whales. Bottom
trawling is the biggest threat to these habitats, where
recovery from trawling is likely to take
centuries.
“What the fishing industry is doing right
now is from a classic playbook. When an industry knows
change is needed, due to clear scientific evidence and loss
of social licence, they fight tooth and nail to make any
change to the status quo seem catastrophic,” says
Greenpeace’s Ellie Hooper.
“Many industries have
used these tactics before – from car makers campaigning
against seatbelts, to tobacco companies trying to cast doubt
on the health risks of smoking.
“The thing is – bottom
trawling’s impacts on these incredible habitats is no
longer up for debate, and the industry is desperately making
claims about the consequences of any ocean protection in a
bid to block progress that is long overdue.
“The
fishing industry has done this for decades, and as such
ocean protection in Aotearoa is drastically behind, and
ocean health seriously in decline. We need politicians to
hold the line, do what is right, what is backed up by
scientific evidence and the public mandate. Anything less is
caving to industry pressure.”
Environmental groups
point to work completed under the last Labour government, in
2022, that shows how protecting seamounts in Aotearoa could
be done and the minimal impact it would have on
fisheries.
“Do not delay,” says Hooper. “This is the
moment to protect seamounts from bottom trawling.
Politicians must take up that mantle and do it by the end of
2027, or they risk years of further inaction and ocean
decline.”
Notes:
1.Seamounts “at risk” from
trawling refers to all 366 seamounts and features of 100m or
more height, within trawl depths (above 1,600m) inside the
EEZ trawl footprint and open to trawling.
2.”The
analysis [by FNZ-MPI] found that 3.5% of the total volume of
all deep-water fisheries (hake, hoki, jack mackerel, ling,
oreo, orange roughy, southern blue whiting, scampi and arrow
squid) is caught on all of the UTFs [seamounts, knolls and
hills] over 100m in elevation, based on the average of the
12-year period (2007 – 2019) (table 1).” 23 June 2022
FNZ-MPI.
3.There are alternatives to bottom trawling
in many fisheries, for example: ling is caught on bottom
longlines and by potting; hoki, southern blue whiting, jack
mackerel and squid can be caught by mid-water trawling which
doesn’t touch the bottom; snapper is caught by bottom
longlines.

