18 November 2026
Civil liberties group PILLAR NZ
condemns Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown’s comment that
“democracy has had its day” as a betrayal of the
democratic principles underpinning the very office he
holds.
“To dismiss democracy while praising
China’s authoritarian system shows contempt for the
democratic norms that underpin New Zealanders’ freedom,
flourishing and prosperity,” says Arian Tashakkori of
PILLAR NZ.
“China’s economic growth does not
excuse political repression. Nor does frustration with
democratic decision-making justify celebrating a communist
dictatorship.
“Democracy gives Kiwis the right to
question their leaders, scrutinise their decisions and
replace them at an election. The mayor should recognise the
irony: those living under a communist dictatorship cannot
criticise their Government in the way he so frequently does
here in NZ.”
Brown’s comments are particularly
reckless against the backdrop of repeated warnings about
foreign interference in New Zealand from our intelligence
services.
The NZSIS’s 2026 Security Threat
Environment Report identifies the People’s Republic of
China as the most active foreign state conducting
interference in New Zealand. It also identifies China as the
only country it has detected conducting espionage here at
scale.
The report warns that politicians, candidates
and politically influential people have been targeted by
foreign interference activity. These warnings demand
vigilance from elected representatives, including in local
government.
Advertisement – scroll to continue reading
“Defending the public’s right to
choose and hold its leaders accountable should be a basic
expectation of everyone in public office,” says
Tashakkori.
“Our elected representatives should be
strengthening confidence in democracy and taking foreign
interference seriously, yet Brown’s comments fail on both
counts.”
PILLAR NZ’s work against foreign
interference is grounded in protecting and promoting
democracy, democratic institutions and civil liberties. That
requires both leadership and practical
safeguards.
PILLAR’s Foreign Influence Transparency
(FIT) Bill would require political influence activities
directed by foreign principals to be publicly disclosed
through a registration framework. Its purpose is to expose
concealed foreign influence, strengthen accountability and
help deter foreign interference.
New Zealand remains
the only country in the 5-Eyes without a foreign agents
register.
“New Zealanders deserve to know when
political influence is being exercised on behalf of a
foreign power, whose interests are being advanced and who is
directing the activity,” says Tashakkori.
“We urge
political parties to support progressing our FIT Bill. The
need for greater transparency extends across central and
local government, and protecting our democratic independence
requires action.
“Democracy has not had its day.
Auckland deserves a mayor prepared to defend
it.”

