No one should be surprised that yesterday’s pay equity
ruling mentions the word “sex” in connection with
women’s rights to pay inequity.
Yesterday’s High
Court ruling found that the Coalition Government’s changes
to the Equal Pay Act discriminated against women and
were inconsistent with the Bill of Rights
Act.
Specifically, the Court found that amendments in
2025 to the Equal Pay Act 1972, were inconsistent with the
right in section 19(1) of the Bill of Rights Act to be free
from discrimination on the ground of sex.
Section
19(1) of the Bill of Rights Act says: “Everyone has the
right to freedom from discrimination on the grounds of
discrimination in the Human Rights Act 1993.”
The
prohibited ground of discrimination relied on here was
“sex”. The Court found that s 19(1) is capable of
including the right to be free from pay inequity. Further, s
19(2) allows for “measures to be taken in good faith for
the purpose of assisting or advancing persons or groups of
persons disadvantaged because of discrimination”, in this
case of women workers because of assumptions and stereotypes
based on their sex.
Despite frequent references to the
“gender pay gap” due to pay inequity, the Equal Pay Act
1972, and its amendments, does not mention the word
“gender”, Women’s Rights Party Co-leader Jill Ovens
says.
Advertisement – scroll to continue reading
“It is all about ‘sex’. The Equal Pay Act,
which contains the provisions relating to pay equity, is an
‘Act to make provision for the removal and prevention of
discrimination, based on the sex of the employees, in the
rates of remuneration of males and females in paid
employment.’, Ms Ovens says.
“The Act in all its
subsequent amendments has never sought to reinterpret the
word ‘sex’ in ‘sex discrimination’ to mean
‘gender’, a concept that is not defined in
law.”
The Act covers both pay equity and pay
equality. Pay equality is the principle that there should be
no difference on the basis of sex between the rates that are
paid by an employer to its male and female
employees.
Pay equity looks beyond an employer’s
particular employees. It looks more broadly to comparators
in the marketplace to ensure that work performed
predominantly by women is not undervalued and therefore
underpaid, a material disadvantage.
The Court found
that material disadvantage had been caused through the
changes to the scheme causing existing pay equity claims to
be terminated, increasing the threshold for pay equity
claims to be brought, preventing pay equity issues to be
identified and addressed for 10 years following settlements,
preventing the use of comparators outside of claimant
groups’ industries or sectors and by making the process
more burdensome for claimants pursuing qualifying
claims.
In his judgement, Justice Paul Radich said the
changes were made mainly to save money, rather than fix a
broken system.
The declaration of inconsistency does
not revoke last year’s changes to the law or restore the
extinguished claims, but the next government will have to
issue a formal response to be debated by MPs. The Crown
could also yet appeal.
Pay Equity legislation allows
for claimants and male comparators to be evaluated against
agreed factors following interviews with role
holders.
The factors take into account things like
level of qualifications required, skills required (could be
fine skills like suturing), emotional demands (as in work
that involves caring for people), exposure to hazards, and
more.
Some male- dominated occupations might score
highly against certain factors, while female- dominated
occupations might score highly on others. They might score
the same, but for different reasons, e.g. different types of
hazards.
Within occupations there are differences,
e.g. a registered nurse or a senior nurse or a nurse
practitioner, and different male comparators will be more
similar than others to one or more of these roles.
The
employer and union parties to the pay equity claim might
disagree on the choice of comparators. They might disagree
on the weightings given. In regulated workforces, there
might be different understandings about the regulations
pertaining to that sector.
That is why pay equity
claims can take five years or more to settle. However, the
parties are required to act in good faith towards each other
and try to reach agreement. There are milestones to be met
along the way.
At the end of the process there is a
negotiation between the employer(s) and the union(s) as to
the extent of the undervaluation based on the evidence, and
what is needed to address any pay
differential.
NOTE: Ms Ovens led the
midwives pay equity claim as Co-leader (Industrial) for
MERAS, the union for employed midwives, between 2017 and
2023.

