Lisa
Meehan, Auckland
University of Technology
The High
Court has ruled New Zealand’s 2025 pay equity reforms
unjustifiably discriminate against women.
Yet the
law remains in force. And the government is under no legal
obligation to reverse the changes. How can that
be?
The answer goes beyond pay equity. The judgement
exposes a wider vulnerability in New Zealand’s system of
human rights protection: what happens when parliament itself
passes legislation that breaches fundamental
rights?
New Zealand has a single-chamber
parliament, permissive rules for passing legislation under
urgency, and courts that cannot invalidate laws simply
because they breach the Bill
of Rights Act.
The pay equity case demonstrates
what happens when these features come
together.
How did we get here?
The
challenge against the government’s overhaul
of the Equal Pay Act in May 2025 was brought by five
unions representing workers in predominantly female
occupations, including nursing, education and public
services.
Advertisement – scroll to continue reading
Equal pay means men and women receive the
same pay for doing the same job. Pay equity goes further: it
means equal pay for work of equal value, even when the jobs
are different. It aims to address the historical
undervaluation of work predominantly performed by
women.
Our earlier
analysis shows why this matters. Women have moved into
traditionally male professions in large numbers, but men
have not moved into female-dominated occupations to the same
extent. Professions like nursing and care work remain
overwhelmingly female.
When entire occupations are
undervalued, equal pay within those jobs does not address
wider gender pay gaps.
The 2025 amendments
immediately cancelled 33 existing pay equity claims. They
also made it harder to bring future claims.
The
government argued these changes would make the system more
robust and financially sustainable.
But in his November
19 judgement, Justice Paul Radich found the amended law
discriminated against women in female-dominated occupations
and materially disadvantaged them.
His judgement
also concluded the restrictions went further than necessary
to achieve the government’s stated objectives, making the
discrimination unjustified.
Who pays for the
budget savings?
The judgement confirms what critics
argued at the time: the pay equity overhaul was driven
primarily by fiscal concerns, rather than evidence that the
existing system was failing.
Fiscal sustainability
is a legitimate concern. Governments face competing demands
on limited resources. But savings in one part of the budget
are not necessarily savings to government
overall.
Our
research on the 2023 social worker pay equity settlement
found higher wages reduced workers’ reliance on income
support and tax credits, while also increasing their
likelihood of remaining employed.
Restricting pay
equity settlements may therefore reduce wage costs, but some
of these savings could be offset by higher government
support payments and lower tax revenue.
Meanwhile,
workers continue to bear the cost of their work being
undervalued.
Why does the law still
stand?
Despite the High Court ruling, the law
still stands because of New Zealand’s constitutional
arrangements.
Under the Bill of Rights Act, courts
cannot invalidate legislation merely because it is
inconsistent with protected rights.
They can
instead issue a declaration of inconsistency, formally
identifying the breach. Such a declaration is significant,
but its practical effects are limited.
Once the
declaration becomes final, the attorney-general must notify
parliament. A select committee considers it, and the
government must formally respond.
However,
parliament is not required to change the inconsistent
law.
The next government could therefore simply
acknowledge the court’s findings while leaving the
discriminatory provisions in place.
A wider
question about democracy
The judgement raises
another uncomfortable issue.
The unions also
challenged the way the legislation was passed. The
government introduced
the amendments under urgency on May 6 2025, taking them
through all three parliamentary readings that day, without
select committee scrutiny or public
submissions.
Yet the court rejected the argument
that this process was unlawful. Unless legislation
specifically requires it, governments have no legal
obligation to consult before introducing a bill.
Parliament also
has broad discretion to pass legislation under urgency,
and courts cannot review its decision to do so. What is
legally permissible, however, is not necessarily good
democratic practice.
Other democracies also
fast-track legislation. But Australia
has an upper house that can reject bills. Norway,
despite having a unicameral parliament, requires at least
three days between legislative readings and allows courts to
review legislation’s constitutionality.
New
Zealand does not have these safeguards.
Parliament
has tightened
its standing orders for the next term, requiring
ministers to justify bypassing select committee scrutiny.
But a parliamentary majority can still approve that
shortcut.
Moreover, standing orders are
parliament’s own rules, which a majority can amend. These
safeguards therefore depend heavily on political
restraint.
What happens
next?
Responsibility now rests with the next
government.
National, ACT and New Zealand First
backed the 2025 changes and have given no indication of
plans to reverse them. By contrast, Labour, the
Greens, Te
Pāti Māori and the
Opportunity Party support restoring the previous pay
equity framework.
But whichever parties form the
next government, the High Court’s declaration does not
legally compel them to act.
That brings us back to
the wider question.
How well does New Zealand
protect fundamental rights when parliament itself is
responsible for breaching them?
The courts can
identify unjustified discrimination, but they cannot
necessarily provide a remedy. In a system with few other
checks on parliamentary power, protecting those rights
ultimately depends heavily on the choices of elected
representatives.
Is that a sufficient
safeguard?![]()
Lisa
Meehan, Director, NZ Policy Research Institute, Auckland
University of Technology
This
article is republished from The Conversation
under a Creative Commons license. Read the original
article.


